Somewhere between "deck the halls" and "why is there a possum on my porch again," this collection was born. This year's Christmas 2026 lineup leans into two things Mending My Faith customers keep asking for: the sillier side of the season (possums, geese, chickens with something to say) and the sacred side (Wise Men, a Savior born, peace wrapped up and given). Whether you're shopping for the animal-lover, the "I need something funny under the tree" friend, or the woman who wants her faith front and center this Christmas, here are 15 gift-worthy picks.
For the Animal Lover Who Needs a Laugh
Festive Opossum T-Shirt — Possum-lover Christmas gifts are having a real moment this year, and this design is your best entry into that trend. A great pick for the friend who's already seen the "overstimulated but festive" jokes and needs a shirt to match.
Festive Chicken T-Shirt and North Pole Egg Dealer T-Shirt — Two chicken-lover gifts for the backyard-flock friend on your list. One's playful and festive, the other leans into the pun — pick based on how much she loves a dad joke.
Christmas Goose T-Shirt — Riding the "silly goose" wave that's everywhere in gift shops this year. A fun, low-effort, guaranteed-smile gift for the friend with a goose-shaped sense of humor.
Grace Owl T-Shirt — For the woman who loves a woodland-creature gift with a little more meaning tucked inside — this one pairs an owl design with a message of grace, not just a punchline.
Merry Frog T-Shirt and Warm Cocoa Frog T-Shirt — Two frog-lover Christmas gifts for the friend whose favorite critter isn't a reindeer. Warm Cocoa Frog leans cozy; Merry Frog leans playful.
3 Kitty Christmas T-Shirt — The cat-lover Christmas gift for the woman whose tree ornaments have already been knocked off twice this month.
Dog Lover Christmas T-Shirt and Puppy Christmas T-Shirt — Two dog-lover Christmas shirts for anyone whose "kids" have four legs and a Santa hat.
Otter Ornament T-Shirt and Giraffe Christmas T-Shirt — For the friend whose favorite animal isn't on anyone else's Christmas shirt list. Unexpected, specific, and exactly the kind of gift that gets remembered.
Be Still Bear T-Shirt — Part woodland-animal Christmas shirt, part quiet reminder to slow down during the busiest month of the year. A meaningful gift for a mom or mentor who could use the nudge.
For the Woman Who Wants Christmas With Her Faith Out Loud
Wise Men T-Shirt and A Savior Is Born T-Shirt — Two straightforward Christian Christmas gifts for women who want the nativity story front and center.
Adore Him T-Shirt and Wrapped in Peace T-Shirt — Gentle, worship-forward Christmas gifts for the friend who wants her shirt to be a quiet act of devotion this season.
For the Woman Who Just Wants to Laugh Through December
It's Fine Christmas T-Shirt and Festive Dang It T-Shirt — Funny Christmas shirts for women for the friend who's hosting, wrapping, baking, and barely holding it together — in the most loving way possible.
Christmas Activity T-Shirt and Christmas Game T-Shirt — Playful picks for family gatherings, gift exchanges, or the friend who treats Christmas like a competitive sport.
Cocoa Co T-Shirt — A vintage cocoa-shop-sign design that bridges fall and Christmas gratitude — a great gift for the friend who's been wearing this one since October and needs the matching mug to go with it.
Every Shirt on This List
- Made from soft Gildan 64000 tees
- Printed and shipped in the USA
- Buy 2+, get free shipping
- Backed by our 30-Day Make-It-Right Guarantee
Not sure which one she'd pick? Browse the full Christmas 2026 Collection and let her favorite animal — or her favorite verse — decide.