Skip to product information
NEW DROP
Ninety-Nine For One T-Shirt in Black featuring a little lamb looking back with gentle eyes and Luke 15:4 lost sheep grace design

Sizing Guide

Gildan 64000

Regular price $39.99 Sale price  $29.99
Color: Black
Size: S

✅ Less than 1% of our customers use our money back guarantee

Soft, Comfy Tees

30 Day Guarantee

Free Shipping on orders $75+

BUNDLE & SAVE
Buy Any 2
Save $3
Buy Any 3
Save $5
FREE SHIPPING  on orders $75.00+
Savings applied automatically at checkout · Typically ships in 2-3 days
First time here? Sign up for 15% off your first order.

Fit Video

Why You'll Love it

In Luke 15:4, Jesus describes a shepherd who leaves the ninety-nine to find the one sheep that wandered off. This design is for anyone who knows they have been that one more than once, and is grateful He keeps coming.

Shirt Details

FIT VIDEO HERE

SIZE GUIDE HERE

Fit, Feel & Care

  • 100% Ring-Spun Cotton — soft, strong, and made to hold up wash after wash (pre-shrunk for a consistent fit).
  • Breathable Fabric — lightweight comfort that feels good from morning to night.
  • True-to-Size Unisex Fit — a relaxed, easy silhouette designed to fit most body types with ease.
  • Reinforced Durability — Double-needle stitching at the shoulders, armholes, neck, waistband, and sleeves for everyday wear.
  • Seamless Collar — Quarter-turned to reduce creasing and help the shirt keep its shape over time.
  • Tear-Away Label — Removes easily for tag-free comfort, with no scratchy residue.
  • Wash cold inside out, tumble dry low, and don’t iron directly on the design.
Shipping & Returns

Shipping, Returns, & 30-Day Happiness Guarantee

✨ Free shipping on orders $75.00+

  • Flat rate shipping: $4.95 on orders under $75.00
  • Orders are processed and shipped within 2–3 business days
  • Delivery typically takes 2–5 business days after shipping
  • Tracking sent as soon as your order ships

Our 30-Day Happiness Guarantee

We want you to love your purchase. If something isn't right, we'll do everything we reasonably can to make it right — that's on us.

You're covered if:

✅ Your item arrives damaged, defective, or incorrect

✅ You let us know within 30 days of purchase

✅ The item is unused and in the condition you received it

Just email support@mendingmyfaith.com with your order number and a photo of the issue, and we'll take care of a full refund. No forms, no runaround.

Please note: since every item is made to order specifically for you, we generally don't accept returns or exchanges due to sizing — so we'd encourage reviewing the size guide closely before ordering.

We're not a faceless corporation. If something's wrong, just reach out.

Policy subject to change, but we'll always keep it reasonable.

The Faithful also Bought

GILDAN 64000 SOFTSTYLE

Premium Quality Tees

More than just a soft tee. Made from lightweight, 100% ring-spun cotton for everyday comfort, each shirt carries a reminder of faith you can take with you wherever the day leads.

LOCATED IN THE USA

Behind Every Shirt, a Real Person

I'm Amanda — a mom of 3 navigating faith and everything in between. Every design comes from something I've actually lived.

If anything's off with your order, it's me you'll hear from — not a bot.

Faithful Favorites

I'm Fine T-Shirt

Sale price  From $29.99 Regular price $39.99

Praying Overthinker T-Shirt

Sale price  From $29.99 Regular price $39.99

I'm Good T-Shirt

Sale price  From $29.99 Regular price $39.99

Pausing & Praying T-Shirt

Sale price  From $29.99 Regular price $39.99

Checked Again T-Shirt

Sale price  From $29.99 Regular price $39.99

Stubbornness T-Shirt

Sale price  From $29.99 Regular price $39.99

FAQs

Why This One's Different

"He leaves the 99 for the one. Thank you for coming back for me. Again." This shirt is for everyone who has wandered, been found, and wandered again, and is still amazed that the Shepherd keeps showing up.

Luke 15:4 tells the parable of the lost sheep: a shepherd who leaves ninety-nine safe sheep to go after the single one that strayed. This design shows that lamb, small and a little sheepish, with a thank-you that ends in one very honest word: again.

Faith is not a straight line for most of us. We drift, we get distracted, we walk away in small ways, and grace finds us anyway. This shirt holds both the humility of wandering and the joy of being carried home.

Printed on a Gildan 64000 unisex tee in soft, breathable 100% cotton, this shirt is built for everyday comfort. The cream lamb artwork stands out on black and navy, and the fabric holds up wash after wash.

It is a meaningful gift for a friend returning to faith, someone celebrating a fresh start, a small group member, or anyone who loves the parables of Jesus. It pairs well with other grace-centered designs.

The Good Shepherd does not keep count of how many times He has come looking. He simply comes. This shirt is a wearable thank-you for a love that pursues us again and again.

In short: this is a Christian t-shirt featuring a lamb and the words "He leaves the 99 for the one. Thank you for coming back for me. Again." inspired by Luke 15:4, printed on a Gildan 64000 unisex tee. It is a grateful reminder of God's pursuing grace.

Why these Shirts?

Mending My Faith started because I needed a shirt that felt like the inside of my own head — a little anxious, a little tired, still holding onto faith even when it wasn't pretty or put-together. I'm a mom of three, caring for aging parents, running this business mostly from my kitchen table, and most days I'm somewhere between "I've got this" and "please, God, help me." Every design we make starts there — with something true, not something that just sounds nice on a t-shirt. We want you to feel a little less alone in whatever you're carrying, and to be reminded that God is right there in the middle of it with you. Cool shirt first. Christian shirt on the reread.

What size should I buy?

View our Fit Video Here

View our Size Guide Here

We want you to feel confident in your purchase. To help you choose the best fit, we've provided a detailed size guide and a fit video on this page for reference.

If you still have questions about sizing, we're here to help. Reach out to us at Support@mendingmyfaith.com before placing your order, and we'll do our best to help you find the perfect fit.

Where are you located?

We’re a U.S.-based brand, and our tees are printed right here in the USA—primarily in Florida and Texas.

At this time, we ship within the United States only.

Do you ship internationally?

Not yet — right now we ship within the United States only, and we're working on reaching more countries soon. Check our shipping policy for rates and delivery times.

What if something goes wrong with my order?

Our 30-Day Happiness Guarantee

We want you to love your purchase. If something isn't right, we'll do everything we reasonably can to make it right — that's on us.

You're covered if:

✅ Your item arrives damaged, defective, or incorrect

✅ You let us know within 30 days of purchase

✅ The item is unused and in the condition you received it

Just email support@mendingmyfaith.com with your order number and a photo of the issue, and we'll take care of a full refund.

Please note: since every item is made to order specifically for you, we generally don't accept returns or exchanges due to sizing — so we'd encourage reviewing the size guide closely before ordering.

Policy subject to change, but we'll always keep it reasonable.

Will I get a tracking number for my order?

Yes! As soon as your order ships, we'll email you a tracking number so you can follow your package all the way to your door.

Customer Reviews

Overall rating: 5 / 5 from 77 reviews.

Customer video review of It's Fall Y'all T-Shirt

Not only is the message one I love, but the quality of the shirt is fantastic. It is so soft and had very minimal shrinkage after being washed. I look forward to my next shirt, your designs are so witty and inspirational.

It's Fall Y'all T-Shirt

Store owner replied: Thank you so much, Tim! We’re so glad you love both the message and the feel of your shirt. Hearing that you’re already looking forward to your next one means a lot to us! We’ll keep working on those witty little reminders that point us back to faith. ❤️

Customer video review of It Is Well Fall T-Shirt

Absolutely love this shirt! This shirt is perfect for fall! It arrived so quickly, and the fabric is incredibly soft — definitely one of my new favorites. Already looking forward to ordering more!

It Is Well Fall T-Shirt

Store owner replied: Thank you so much for sharing this — your video absolutely made our day! 🥰 We're so glad you love your shirt as much as we loved making it. Thank you for supporting our small business, it truly means the world to us! 💛

Customer photo review of I'm Fine T-Shirt

Good quality shirt and good quality print! Love it!

I'm Fine T-Shirt

Store owner replied: Thank you so much for the kind words! 🥰 We're so glad the quality — both the shirt and the print — lived up to expectations. That means a lot to us as a small business! Thanks for supporting Mending My Faith. 💛

Customer photo review of I'm Fine T-Shirt

Came fast. Fits true to size. Nice quality T-shirt.

I'm Fine T-Shirt

Store owner replied: Melissa, thank you so much for sharing this photo — it made my whole day! I love seeing "I'm Fine" out in the world like this. So glad it fit true to size and arrived quickly for you. Thank you for supporting Mending My Faith! 🤍

Customer photo review of Letting Go T-Shirt

From the founder: I made this design in a season where I needed to let go of trying to figure everything out. I ordered it myself to test the experience, but it quickly became a personal reminder I actually reach for. It’s simple, but it speaks right where I am.

Letting Go T-Shirt

Turning an idea into a shirt. You have a gift!

Change Focus T-Shirt

Store owner replied: This made my day! Thank you for trusting me with your idea. Seeing it go from a conversation to a real shirt was so special. If another one comes to you, you know where to find me! 💛

Love this shirt! I'll definitely order again.

I'm Fine T-Shirt

Store owner replied: Thank you so much! I'm so glad you love it. Can't wait to see what you pick next time! 💛

Great product and fast delivery!

Dog, I'm Fine T-Shirt

Store owner replied: Thank you so much! I'm so glad it arrived quickly and that you love it. Enjoy wearing it! 💛

Great product and fast delivery!

God's Timing T-Shirt

Store owner replied: Thank you for ordering again and taking the time to leave reviews! It means so much. Blessings to you! 🙏

Great product!

I Lied T-Shirt

Store owner replied: Thank you so much! So glad you love it. 💛

I gave this one as a gift and my friend loved it! She loves the quality and size of the shirt. Thank y'all for a pleasant experience!

Stubbornness T-Shirt

Store owner replied: Terri, this made my day! There's nothing better than hearing a gift was a hit. Thank you for thinking of us, and please tell your friend to wear it proudly! 😊

I wore this to work and got so many comments on it! I referred several people to the site; so I'm hoping more business will come your way!

I'm Fine T-Shirt

Store owner replied: Terri, you're the best! I love that it got people talking at work, and thank you so much for sending friends our way. Word of mouth means the world to a small business like mine. 💛

I love the shirts I got! They fit perfectly!! Great quality!

It's Fine Christmas T-Shirt

Store owner replied: Thank you so much! I'm thrilled the fit and quality are just right. Enjoy every one of them! 💛

Wore it to bible study, they all loved it and many could relate!! :)

I'm Fine T-Shirt

Store owner replied: Thank you, Peggy! It's such a blessing that it opened up real conversations. There's freedom in admitting we're not always fine, and He meets us right there. 🙏

Such a fun non threatening way to witness

I'm Fine T-Shirt

Store owner replied: Thank you! That's exactly the heart behind it: a little humor that opens the door to a real conversation about Jesus. So glad you love it! 💛

At a glance, this sweatshirt may seem a little pricey, but I’m here to tell you it’s worth every penny. It is soft and comfortable and sturdy and feels like God is giving you a hug. I needed a 4X and they were able to get that for me. The sleeves are too long for me so I am having them taken up because it’s worth it to me to make this sweatshirt perfect. I will buy more.. I give this a 10 out of 10.

Be Still Cat Sweatshirt

Store owner replied: Mary, thank you so much for this wonderful review! ❤️ Hearing you describe the sweatshirt as feeling like “God is giving you a hug” absolutely made our day. We’re also so glad we could get the 4X for you and that you love the softness and comfort. Thank you for trusting us with your order and for taking the time to share this—it truly means so much to us. Wear it in good faith! ❤️

Very nice quality shirt! Quick delivery. Had a great buying experience!

Praying Overthinker T-Shirt

Store owner replied: Thank you so much! We’re so glad you loved the quality of your shirt and had a great experience from ordering to delivery. We truly appreciate you choosing Mending My Faith! ❤️

So many to choose from! Bought one for each of my friends....and a few for me! Delivery was fast. Love them!

Praying Overthinker T-Shirt

Store owner replied: Thank you so much, Kriss! ❤️ We love that you found shirts for your friends—and couldn’t resist a few for yourself too! 😊 It means so much knowing these messages are being shared with people you care about. We’re so glad you love them!

Very good quality and good fit.

Inhale Peace T-Shirt

Store owner replied: Thank you so much! We’re so glad you’re happy with the quality and fit of your shirt. We hope Inhale Peace serves as a little reminder to pause, breathe, and trust God throughout your day. ❤️

Excellent product that arrived very quickly

I'm Fine T-Shirt

Store owner replied: Thank you so much! We’re so glad you love your I’m Fine tee and that it arrived quickly. We hope it brings a few smiles—and maybe a knowing laugh—every time you wear it! ❤️

Beautiful and exactly as described.

Smaller Table T-Shirt

Store owner replied: Thank you so much! ❤️ This design was created from a story very close to our own hearts, so hearing that you think it’s beautiful means more than you know. We hope it brings you a little comfort and encouragement every time you wear it.

I already sent a review.

Checked Again 4XL & 5XL T-Shirt

Store owner replied: Thank you so much! We really appreciate you taking the time to leave us a review—and for the 5 stars! ❤️

Love this shirt. Verse is so true with a human twist.

I'm Fine T-Shirt

Store owner replied: Thank you so much! ❤️ That’s exactly what we hoped this shirt would be—a little truth from Scripture with an honest, very human twist. We’re so glad you love it!

Perfect

I'm Fine T-Shirt

Store owner replied: Thank you so much! ❤️ We’re so glad you love your I’m Fine tee. Sometimes “perfect” says it all! 😊

Love this shirt. Love the design. This shirt is made of good quality fabric. Nice weight for year round wearing. The design makes me smile.

I'm Fine T-Shirt

Store owner replied: Thank you so much, Sylvia! ❤️ We love hearing that the design makes you smile—that’s exactly what we hoped it would do. We’re also so glad you’re enjoying the quality and feel of the shirt. We hope it brings you lots of smiles all year long!

Start your day out, saying, "Wow! What a God You are!" (and wear this shirt to keep reminding yourself all day).

What A God T-Shirt

Store owner replied: Dawn, we LOVE this! ❤️ And we love having you as part of the Mending My Faith community. So many of your wonderful ideas and suggestions have found their way onto shirts in our shop, and we always look forward to hearing what you come up with next! Thank you for continuing to support us, encourage us, and share your creativity with us. And yes—“Wow! What a God You are!” is a pretty wonderful way to start the day. ❤️

Soft shirt. Great message!

Love Forever Song T-Shirt

Store owner replied: Thank you so much! ❤️ We’re so glad you’re enjoying the softness of your shirt and, even more importantly, the message behind it. We hope it’s a reminder you’ll love wearing again and again!

I’m very pleased with the T-shirt that I ordered. I bought it as a gift for a woman of faith who is also a cat lover so the combination is purr-fect and I’m sure she’ll love it. I am also happy with the quality of the shirt and how promptly it arrived. Thanks and God bless! Donna T.

I'm Fine T-Shirt

Store owner replied: Donna, thank you so much for your kind review! I love that you chose this shirt as a gift for a fellow cat lover, and I hope she loves it just as much as you do. I’m also so glad you were happy with the quality and quick delivery. Your support truly means a lot to us. God bless! ❤️ — Amanda, Mending My Faith

I loved the shirt!!

Pausing & Praying T-Shirt

Store owner replied: Thank you so much! I’m so happy to hear you loved the shirt. I truly appreciate you taking the time to leave a review and support Mending My Faith. God bless! — Amanda❤️

T-shirts could’ve arrived quicker.

Professional Overthinker T-Shirt

Store owner replied: Thank you for your feedback. I’m glad your shirt arrived safely, and I’m sorry the delivery took longer than you expected. We’re always looking for ways to make the experience better, and I truly appreciate your patience and your support of Mending My Faith. — Amanda

Shirts are very soft, roomy, and good quality. I love wearing them because it helps me to share my faith because people will comment on them.

Pausing & Praying T-Shirt

Store owner replied: Terri, thank you so much for sharing this. I love hearing that the shirt is not only comfortable, but also giving you opportunities to share your faith with others. That is exactly what I hope these designs can do—open the door to meaningful conversations. I truly appreciate your support. God bless! — Amanda

I love the shirt

I'm Fine T-Shirt

Store owner replied: Thank you! I’m so happy the shirt was a hit. It means a lot to know one of our designs found a place in your closet. I hope you enjoy wearing it for a long time to come! — Amanda, Mending My Faith

Well made. It’s too long for me, but it will make a great gift!!

Pausing & Praying T-Shirt

Store owner replied: Thank you so much! ❤️ We’re glad you loved the quality, even if the length wasn’t quite right for you. We hope it makes the perfect gift and brings a little encouragement to whoever receives it!

I received a lot of giggles and and grins from people at church.

I'm Fine T-Shirt

Store owner replied: Thank you so much! ❤️ We love hearing that your shirt brought some smiles and laughter at church. That’s exactly the kind of joy we hope these designs bring!

First, Amazing customer service. They had no sweatshirts available online. I reached out and asked and they delivered. Asked sizing and color and they delivered. Very comfortable and soft! Sizing is 100% true. Would definitely order again. Anne

Pausing. Praying. Editing Sweatshirt

Store owner replied: Thank you so much, Anne! We’re so glad we were able to help get the sweatshirt you wanted and that the fit was perfect. It means a lot to us that you took the time to share your experience. We hope you love wearing your Pausing. Praying. Editing. sweatshirt! ❤️

Very comfortable!!! I’ve gotten a lot of comments!😊

Philippians 4:13 T-Shirt

Store owner replied: Thank you so much, Royce! 😊 We’re so glad you’re loving the comfort — and hearing that your shirt is getting lots of comments makes us smile! We hope it continues to be a little reminder of Philippians 4:13 everywhere you wear it. ❤️

I’m happy with my purchase!

I'm Fine T-Shirt

Store owner replied: Thank you so much! ❤️ We’re so happy you love your I’m Fine tee. We hope it gives you a little smile—and a reminder to keep giving it back to God—every time you wear it! 😊

Love the feel of the shirt. Great quality and the print is perfect

Ain't No Ghost T-Shirt

Store owner replied: Nothing makes us happier than hearing the shirt feels as good as the message means. 🎃👻

Nice quality T. Everyone loved the graphic.

I'm Fine T-Shirt

Store owner replied: Thank you so much for taking the time to leave this review! It means the world to hear the graphic was a hit — that little "I'm Fine" cat has a special place in my heart, and I'm so glad it made people smile. Thanks for supporting Mending My Faith! 🤍

Love all your shirts. The 2 I’ve already worn have also been enjoyed by those reading it.

It Is Well Fall T-Shirt

Store owner replied: Linnese, this made me smile so much! I love that your shirts are sparking conversations with the people around you — that's exactly the heart behind what we do here. Thank you for the kind words and for being a repeat wearer of Mending My Faith! 🤍