Skip to product information
Green t-shirt with white text that reads Prayed. Overthinking. Praying again on a wooden surface
1/3
 

Prayed. Overthinking. Praying Again. T-Shirt

Color: Military Green
Size: Please choose a size
Size Guide
SALE
Regular price  $39.99 Sale price  $29.99

Soft, meaningful, and made for everyday wear.

You pray about it, feel peace for a moment, then find yourself replaying every possible outcome in your mind. This Christian t-shirt is a gentle reminder that when overthinking returns, you can return to prayer too.

✅ Less than 1% of customers use our money back guarantee.

30-Day Guarantee

Fast

Shipping

Buy with Confidence

Sizing Guide & Fit Video

Watch our Fit Video

Our shirts follow the industry standard shirt sizes:

  • S: Chest width: 18" | Length: 28"
  • M: Chest width: 20" | Length: 29"
  • L: Chest width: 22" | Length: 30"
  • XL: Chest width: 24" | Length: 31"
  • 2XL: Chest width: 26" | Length: 32"
  • 3XL: Chest width: 28" | Length: 33"

Chest width (different from 'bust') is measured across, not around. (Start at one inch below the armhole when laid flat)

Length is measured from the highest

point of the shoulder down to the bottom of the tee.

For the perfect fit, find a shirt that fits you well and measure.

Most customers order their normal t-shirt size.

Please review the sizing guide carefully before ordering, as each item is made to order specifically for you. For that reason, we generally do not accept returns or exchanges due to sizing.

About this Design

At Mending My Faith, our designs are created as wearable reminders rooted in Scripture and real-life faith. Life moves quickly, responsibilities grow heavy, and it is easy for our thoughts to drift toward stress, anxiety, overwhelm, fear, discouragement, and overthinking. Sometimes we do not need a brand-new answer, we simply need to be reminded again of what is true.

These Christian t-shirts were created for believers carrying more than they can handle on their own. For the Christian mom trying to hold everything together. For the exhausted caregiver. For the overthinker replaying every conversation. For the believer navigating waiting seasons, mental exhaustion, difficult circumstances, emotional overwhelm, or the pressure of everyday life while still trying to keep their focus on God.

Inspired by Scripture and honest faith, these designs serve as gentle reminders to pause, breathe, pray, trust God, and redirect anxious thoughts back toward truth and peace. Many Christians searching for faith-based encouragement for anxiety, stress, burnout, overthinking, peace of mind, waiting on God, emotional exhaustion, identity in Christ, and spiritual encouragement connect with these messages because they reflect real struggles and real faith.

These shirts also make meaningful Christian gifts for moms, dads, friends, caregivers, ministry leaders, students, overthinkers, and anyone who could use daily encouragement rooted in God’s promises.

Questions People Often Have

Who are these shirts designed for?
These designs were created for Christians navigating real-life struggles like anxiety, overthinking, stress, burnout, emotional overwhelm, waiting seasons, discouragement, and mental exhaustion while trying to keep their faith anchored in God.

Would these shirts make meaningful Christian gifts?
Yes. These designs are often purchased as encouraging gifts for Christian moms, dads, friends, students, caregivers, ministry leaders, counselors, and loved ones walking through stressful or emotionally exhausting seasons.

What makes Mending My Faith different from other Christian apparel brands?
Mending My Faith focuses on wearable reminders rooted in Scripture, emotional honesty, and everyday faith. Instead of generic inspirational messages, these designs are intentionally created to help redirect thoughts, interrupt mental spirals, and point believers back toward peace, truth, grace, and trust in God.

Shirt Details & Care

Made & shipped in the USA. Quality you can feel from the first wear.

Fit, Feel & Care

  • 100% Ring-Spun Cotton — soft, strong, and made to hold up wash after wash (pre-shrunk for a consistent fit).
  • Breathable Fabric — lightweight comfort that feels good from morning to night.
  • True-to-Size Unisex Fit — a relaxed, easy silhouette designed to fit most body types with ease.
  • Reinforced Durability — Double-needle stitching at the shoulders, armholes, neck, waistband, and sleeves for everyday wear.
  • Seamless Collar — Quarter-turned to reduce creasing and help the shirt keep its shape over time.
  • Tear-Away Label — Removes easily for tag-free comfort, with no scratchy residue.
  • Wash cold inside out, tumble dry low, and don’t iron directly on the design.
Shipping & Returns

Free shipping on orders $75+

  • Flat rate shipping: $4.75 on all other orders
  • Orders are processed and shipped within 2–3 business days
  • Delivery typically takes 2–5 business days after shipping
  • Tracking sent as soon as your order ships

Returns:
The "Something Went Wrong" Policy

We want you to love your purchase. If something isn't right, please let us know and we'll do everything we reasonably can to help.

If something arrives damaged, defective, or just plain wrong, we'll make it right - that's on us.

Here's the deal:

  • Got something damaged or defective? Full refund, no questions asked.
  • Have 30 days from purchase to let us know
  • Item needs to be unused and in the condition you received it
  • Email us at support@mendingmyfaith.com - No Ai, no customer service bot, just a real human response.

We're not a faceless corporation. If something's wrong, just reach out. No worries, no drama.

Policy subject to change, but we'll always keep it reasonable.

30-Day Guarantee Details

Our goal is for you to love your order, and we strive for 100% satisfaction guarantee. Please contact us if something isn’t right.

✅ Incorrect, damaged, or defective items are eligible for a full refund.
✅ Refund requests must be made within 30 days of the purchase date.

For refund inquiries, please contact us at support@mendingmyfaith.com

Eligibility for a Refund

✅ Product received is damaged or defective.
✅ The request is made within 30 days of purchase.
✅ Item must be unused and returned in its original condition.

For any return questions, contact us at: support@mendingmyfaith.com within 30 days of delivery with your order number and a photo of the issue.

Please review the sizing guide carefully before ordering, as each item is made to order specifically for you. For that reason, we generally do not accept returns or exchanges due to sizing.

Policy subject to change, but we'll always keep it reasonable.

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

I absolutely love my "Cast Your Cares" Christian T-Shirt. Great quality fabric, very soft, and fits perfectly. Fast shipping and wonderful customer service.

-Verified Customer.

Worn in real life

For the quiet, everyday moments where you need something steady.

More Than a T-Shirt

Thoughtful designs created to encourage your heart, redirect your thoughts, and point you back to God.

Comfortable to wear. Meaningful to carry.

Customer service with kindness in mind

Got a question or need help? Our dedicated customer service team is here to ensure you have the best experience.

For the days you need something to hold onto

We’ll take care of you

If something isn’t right, we’ll make it right.

Quickly, personally, no stress.

Buying FAQ's

What size should I buy?

View our Fit Video Here

We want you to feel confident in your purchase. To help you choose the best fit, we've provided a detailed size guide and a fit video on this page for reference.

If you still have questions about sizing, we're here to help. Reach out to us at Support@mendingmyfaith.com before placing your order, and we'll do our best to help you find the perfect fit.

Where are you located?

We’re a U.S.-based brand, and our tees are printed right here in the USA—primarily in Florida and Texas.

At this time, we ship within the United States only.

Do you ship internationally?

Not yet—we currently ship within the United States only.

We hope to offer international shipping in the near future, so check back for updates.

Will I get a tracking number for my order?

Yes—once your order ships, you’ll receive an email with tracking so you can follow it all the way to your doorstep.

What if something goes wrong with my order?

Our goal is for you to love your order, and we strive for 100% satisfaction guarantee. Please contact us if something isn’t right.

✅ Incorrect, damaged, or defective items are eligible for a full refund.
✅ Refund requests must be made within 30 days of the purchase date.

For refund inquiries, please contact us at support@mendingmyfaith.com

Eligibility for a Refund

✅ Product received is damaged or defective.
✅ The request is made within 30 days of purchase.
✅ Item must be unused and returned in its original condition.

For any return questions, contact us at: support@mendingmyfaith.com within 30 days of delivery with your order number and a photo of the issue.

Please review the sizing guide carefully before ordering, as each item is made to order specifically for you. For that reason, we generally do not accept returns or exchanges due to sizing.

Policy subject to change, but we'll always keep it reasonable.